A Comparison of Mr Coffee vs Keurig Coffee Makers

Photo of author

Johny Morrisson

If you’re a coffee lover, you’re no stranger to the battle between Keurig and Mr. Coffee.

In the world of coffee makers, these two giants have emerged as front-runners, each competing for a spot in your kitchen and your heart.

In this caffeine-fueled showdown of Keurig vs Mr Coffee, I’ll compare the features, technologies, and Pros and Cons of these coffee machines. And compare the top models of both these brands in the end.

Keurig vs Mr coffee

An Overview of Keurig 

Keurig has revolutionized the coffee industry with its single-serve brewing machines. Their introduction of coffee pods, known as K-Cups, created a new level of convenience for coffee lovers.

Keurig made the brewing process as simple as possible. Place the pod in the machine, press the brew button, and your coffee will be ready in minutes.

Keurig has launched a wide range of models to suit the needs of different customers. From the basic K-Mini Plus to the more advanced K-Supreme Plus Smart and K-cafe, there is a Keurig machine for everyone.

What I Like in Keurig: Convenience, Variety, and Accessibility

Keurig machines excel in convenience, providing a hassle-free brewing experience. All you have to do is simply add water, insert a K-Cup, select the cup size, and brew! No need for coffee grounds or filters, making it quick and easy to enjoy a cup of coffee. 

Additionally, the availability of a vast selection of K-Cups from different brands ensures a variety of flavors and blends to suit every palate. You can also make beverages like tea and hot cocoa using your Keurig machine. Keurig’s popularity has made K-Cups readily available in stores, ensuring accessibility for new and existing customers.

What I Don’t Like in Keurig: Limited Capacity, Lacks Freshness, and Plastic Pods

While Keurig machines are convenient for single-cup brewing, they are not ideal for serving multiple cups simultaneously, unless you opt for a Duo model with dual brewing functionality.

These machines are convenient, but Keurig actually makes a weaker coffee with less flavor. This is because the coffee is made with pre-packaged pods, which are not as fresh as freshly ground coffee.

Additionally, the environmental impact of plastic K-Cups raises concerns about sustainability. Although efforts have been made to recycle K-cup pods, the majority of K-cups still contribute to waste.

An Overview of Mr. Coffee

Mr. Coffee is a popular brand of coffee makers that offers a variety of models to fit different needs and budgets. The brand has been around for over 50 years, and it is known for its affordable machines that produce great-tasting coffee.

Mr. Coffee offers a variety of models, with prices ranging from around $25 to $250, making them an attractive choice for budget-conscious coffee lovers.

Mr. Coffee machines operate similarly to traditional drip coffee makers.

Simply fill the water reservoir to the desired level, add a coffee filter and fresh coffee grounds to the basket, select the desired brew strength, and press the brew button.

Mr. Coffee also offers automatic Espresso machines to prepare cafe-styled specialty coffee drinks quickly.

Mr coffee machines

What I Like in Mr. Coffee: Affordability, Variety, and Ease of Use

Affordability is a key advantage of Mr. Coffee machines. They offer quality brewing performance at budget-friendly prices, providing an accessible option for those looking to enjoy a good cup of coffee without breaking the bank. 

Additionally, Mr. Coffee offers a variety of machines from simple 12-cup coffee makers to pod-based machines to fully automatic Espresso machines.

These machines allow you to brew coffee with coffee grounds and paper filters, giving you the flexibility to choose your favorite coffee without worrying about plastic waste. The machines are also user-friendly, following familiar brewing principles, and are easy to operate and maintain.

What I Don’t Like in Mr. Coffee: Longer Brew Time, Not as convenient as Pod machines

One aspect to consider with Mr. Coffee machines is that brewing a full pot of coffee may take longer compared to single-cup pod machines. This might be a drawback for those who value quick brewing times, especially during busy mornings. 

Mr. Coffee machines are not as convenient as Keurig machines because they require more manual work. You must measure and add coffee grounds and paper filters to the machine, and you must dispose of them properly afterward.

Keurig vs Mr coffee | A Comparison

1. Taste and Quality of Drink

The main difference between Mr. Coffee and Keurig lies in the use of coffee grounds.

Mr. Coffee operates like a traditional drip coffee maker – ground coffee beans are placed in a filter to produce a pot of coffee.

And Keurig uses pre-packaged K-Cups containing measured amounts of coffee.

While Keurig offers convenience and consistency, the taste of the coffee is generally more standardized and much less customizable.

With Mr. Coffee machines, you can make your coffee as strong or as weak as you like by adjusting the coffee-to-water ratio. And if you use freshly ground coffee beans, you can take your drink to the next level of flavors.

Winner: Mr. Coffee is a winner in terms of taste (If you use Fresh coffee beans)

2. Ease of Use

Keurig machines are incredibly easy to use. Just insert a K-Cup pod and press a button, and you’ll have a cup of coffee in minutes.

Mr. Coffee machines are not as easy to use as Keurig machines. They require you to grind and measure ground coffee, fill the filter, and start the brew cycle. However, those familiar with traditional brewing methods will find Mr. Coffee’s machines fairly easy to operate.

If we talk about maintenance and cleaning, both Keurig and Mr. Coffee machines are relatively straightforward. Both need regular cleaning and descaling to remove mineral buildup.

Winner: In terms of Ease of use, Keurig is the clear winner

3. Compatibility

Keurig machines are designed to work with specific types of coffee pods, commonly known as K-cups. Now, Keurig has also introduced reusable My K-Cup filters so you can use your own coffee but it’s not as easy to use as k cup pods.

On the other hand, Mr. Coffee machines are compatible with ground coffee, offering users the flexibility to experiment with various blends.

Winner: Here I declare Mr coffee as a winner as ground coffee is affordable and available in a huge variety, but if you value convenience Keurig is the winner.

4. Price

Mr. Coffee machines are much more affordable compared to Keurig. Their 5-cup and 12-cup brewers are very budget-friendly, and personally, I find them easy to use as well.

You can find a Mr. Coffee machine for as low as $25, while Keurig machines typically start at around $80.

And also it’s much cheaper to use coffee grounds than K cups. You can find good quality coffee beans at less than half the price of K cups.

Winner: In terms of affordability, Mr. Coffee is the clear winner

Also Read: Are Keurigs Worth it?

Keurig K cafe vs Mr Coffee Espresso and Cappuccino Machine

The Keurig K-Cafe is an advanced Keurig model with an automatic milk frother that allows users to create lattes and other coffee drinks with ease.

It can brew concentrated coffee shots and froth fresh milk quickly to prepare creamy lattes or frothy cappuccinos, hot or cold. The machine’s multiple brew sizes and the strong brew button add to its versatility.

The Mr. Coffee Espresso and Cappuccino Machine provides an authentic cafe-style experience with its 15-bar pump system and automatic milk frother.

This is a very budget-friendly automatic Espresso machine that prepares Single and double Espressos and Latte and Cappuccino at the touch of a single button.

Keurig K Cafe and Mr Coffee Cappuccino Machine
FeaturesKeurig K cafe Mr. Coffee Espresso & Cappuccino Machine
Brewing MethodDrip Brewing at normal pressurePressurized Espresso brewing system (15 bars)
Milk FrotherFully automaticFully automatic
Drink Options-Brew Sizes: 6, 8, 10, and 12oz.
-Cappuccino and Latte
-Single and Double Espresso shots
-Cappuccino and Latte
MaterialPlasticStainless Steel
CompatibilityK cup coffee podsEspresso coffee grounds
Special Features– Removable Tank
– Strong brew funtion
– One-touch control panel 
– Programmable
– Removable Tank
– One-touch control panel 

The best machine for you depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you want simplicity and ease of use, the Keurig K-Cafe is a great option. If you want an authentic cappuccino experience, the Mr. Coffee Espresso and Cappuccino Machine is a better choice.

Read a detailed review of Keurig K cafe

Mr. Coffee Iced and Hot Coffee Maker vs Keurig K Mini Plus

The Mr. Coffee Iced and Hot Coffee Maker is a single-serve coffee maker that brews both hot and iced coffee using coffee grounds.

It can prepare up to 16 oz coffee with a very quick brewing time of only 3 minutes.

The Keurig K-Mini Plus excels in its compact and space-saving design, fitting perfectly into any setting.

It has a Strong brew button to cater to those who prefer a bolder brew, and a very portable design with Pods and cord storage that makes it perfect for traveling.

Keurig K mini plus and Mr Coffee Single Serve
FeaturesKeurig K-Mini Plus Mr. Coffee Iced & Hot Coffee Maker
CompatibilityK cup Coffee podsCoffee Grounds
Water TankRemovable 12 ozNon-Removable 16 oz
Special Features– Strong brew feature
– Cord and Pod Storage
– Portable design
– 16 oz coffee Tumblr
– Iced Coffee function
– Reusable coffee filter

The Mr. Coffee Iced and Hot Coffee Maker is a very affordable single-serve option for people who love both iced and hot beverages. While the K-Mini Plus is a compact and easy-to-use coffee maker that is compatible with K-Cup pods.

Read a detailed review of Keurig K Mini Plus

Mr. Coffee 12 cup Coffee Maker vs Keurig K- Duo Plus

The Mr. Coffee Programmable 12 Cup Coffee Maker emphasizes simplicity and classic functionality, providing a no-fuss brewing experience for a pot of coffee.

The coffee maker has a diverse range of features, including an auto-pause feature for convenient pouring before the brew cycle finishes, a strength control feature for a stronger or weaker brew, and a thermal carafe option to keep coffee hot for longer.

The Keurig K-Duo Plus offers versatility with the ability to brew using K-Cup pods or ground coffee as well as the option for single-serve or coffee pot brewing.

It has an elegant modern design and offers modern features like 24-hour programmable brewing, a strong brew function for bolder coffee, and a thermal carafe that keeps coffee hot for a very long time.

Keurig K Duo plus and Mr Coffee 12 cup coffee maker
FeaturesKeurig K- Duo PlusMr. Coffee 12 cup
ModeBoth Single and PotOnly Pot coffee maker
MaterialStainless Steel and PlasticStainless Steel and Plastic
Weight12.5 Pounds4 Pounds
Special Features– Strong Brew
– Multi-position water reservoir
– Thermal Carafe
– Programmable
– Auto Pause
– Strength control option
– Permanent filter
– Both Thermal and Glass Carafe
– Programmable
– Auto Pause

All in all, the Mr. Coffee Coffee Maker excels in straightforward operation and reliable performance, while the Keurig K-Duo Plus stands out with its adaptability, offering the convenience of both single-serve and carafe brewing options. 

Read a detailed review of Keurig K Duo Plus

Final Thoughts

And there you have it—the good, the bad, and the ugly on Keurig vs Mr. Coffee single-serve brewers.

For the swift and convenient morning routine, Keurig’s single-serve prowess is unparalleled. And for those who find solace in a classic pot of coffee at a very affordable price, Mr. Coffee is the best choice

In my personal experience, the convenience and versatility of Keurig have won me over. The quick brewing time and the ability to enjoy various drink options make it a perfect fit for my busy lifestyle.

Drop your thoughts below in the comments on which side won your coffee-loving heart!

Also Read other Keurig comparisons

Johny Morrison is a founder and content creator at Coffee About. He knows everything there is to know about coffee and loves sharing his passion with others.

You can often find him sipping a single-origin pour-over, rich French press, or pulling espresso shots at home. Johny loves full-bodied dark roasts – the bolder, the better!

As a former barista, he takes coffee equipment seriously and enjoys experimenting with the latest gear. When he’s not brewing or blogging, Johny is scouting local cafes for his next coffee fix.

Leave a Comment